U.S. Will Push China on Human Rights — But Not Right Now
My family enjoys watching the offbeat television comedy show, “Big Bang Theory” every Monday evening. In it, the goofy characters — all brilliant but nerdy physicists — constantly play the childhood game “rock-paper-scissors” to help them decide their various daily priorities, like what to eat or what game to play.
The rock-paper-scissors game came to mind last week in reading news accounts of Secretary of State Hillary Clinton’s official visit to China. Despite her pledge as a Presidential candidate to be tough on China’s dismal human rights record — a pledge shared by Barack Obama — it appears that the world’s economic crisis will trump any serious effort, at least anytime soon, by the United States to persuade the Chinese to clean up their persistent abuses of basic human freedoms.
Those abuses are well documented and, unfortunately, pervasive. Last summer’s Beijing Olympics may have been a spectacular success as a sports and entertainment event, but the games came at the expense of ordinary Chinese citizens, thousands of whom were dragooned into huge work gangs to build various Olympic venues with little or no pay. Recent reports out of Africa portray the Chinese as pillaging that continent’s huge natural resources of oil and minerals in sweetheart arrangements with corrupt governments who, in turn, force thousands of destitute Africans to work as virtual slaves extracting the valuable deposits. The Chinese government’s backing of the genocidal government in Sudan should provoke global outrage, but instead has raised nary an eyebrow except among committed human rights activists.
The economic crisis is real, and certainly a top priority for government attention and action. But are human rights and essential freedoms only important when times are good, credit is flowing and jobs are plentiful? Apparently, the rock-paper-scissors answer is that among competing priorities confronting nations, the protection of the rights of individuals must wait for better days.


The economy has to be our number one priority. How is America supposed to dabble in the affairs of other nations when half of America is struggling to pay the bills. Am I sorry that China has such significant human rights issues? Yes. Am I willing to waste time and money on human rights issues on the other side of the globe when that time and money can be spent in an effort to bring us out of this recession? No. The American people need to be this nation’s number one priority.
Robert, you should be ashamed of yourself. The Chinese people need our help and I am angered at the stance Hillary has taken to save face in these economic times. Even at a time of economic turmoil the United States is the only nation in the world who could successfully bring about change and repair the human rights issues in China. We have all read the documented reports of the Chinese workers at the Olympics and the Chinese governmental support of the genocide in the Sudan. How much more proof do we need? How can Hillary say this issue must take a back seat when during her campaign she addressed it as an issue of importance? I am disappointed.
Tyrone, Robert is simply being a realist. Without our markets, capitalism in China will fail. Without capitalism in China the people there will continue to suffer indignities. We need China and China needs us. It’s like putting on an oxygen mask in the airplane – do yours first before you try to assist others. Otherwise we all perish.
the us should not take thy man power to supress the chinese but thy should forcus on thy work
Well, Well, I have been writing about and chiding the US government about our dismal record of friendships with the Human rights abusers around the globe for years, Saudi Arabia, Egypt and Pakistan among them. Our own record on human rights is pretty sorry also.